Full List of our free My first time gay stories

 

Total: 425, Page: 2

 

Gym class gone bad 8.42: vote

Being caught in the locker room can turn bad real quick...

Added: 24-May-2013

Rating: 8.42
Read...
Me and him: Part 5 7.50: vote

Finally it happens...

Added: 26-Apr-2012

Rating: 7.50
Read...
Once, never more 6.00: vote

My first time with my best friend. A hot night in Germany...

Added: 05-Feb-2013

Rating: 6.00
Read...
The Voice that Blew my Heart : Intro 10.00: vote

A little intro to a wonderful love story... come on take a peek.

Added: 25-Feb-2013

Rating: 10.00
Read...
First gay sex 3.30: vote

Forced sex...

Added: 21-Feb-2012

Rating: 3.30
Read...
Our Story: Part 1 7.20: vote

100% fiction. First Part of my story, love story with sex...

Added: 03-Oct-2012

Rating: 7.20
Read...
I and James 7.43: vote

Our first time...

Added: 14-Nov-2012

Rating: 7.43
Read...
Second time with my internet sex mate 5.75: vote

It had been about a month since I had my virginity taken by John, which was also my first time doing anything sexual with a man...

Added: 18-Jun-2012

Rating: 5.75
Read...
My first time with some one unexpected 6.33: vote

I"m 18 he is 22 and it"s the beginning to a hot story...

Added: 01-May-2012

Rating: 6.33
Read...
My first time with the health teacher 5.67: vote

The time my health/football coach fucked me...

Added: 23-Apr-2012

Rating: 5.67
Read...
My first time with a Guy : Part II 10.00: vote

Finally experiencing my first time with a Guy after years of fantasizing...

Added: 16-May-2012

Rating: 10.00
Read...
All in a Daves work 8.00: vote

I found my self looking into his eyes...

Added: 27-Jul-2012

Rating: 8.00
Read...
My best friend 4.00: vote

My first time having sex was with my friend...

Added: 18-Apr-2012

Rating: 4.00
Read...
My first time 4.00: vote

the first time took me by suprise.

Added: 01-Jul-2012

Rating: 4.00
Read...
Malboro Tony 3 : My First Gay Experience 7.67: vote

Marcus tells his story about his first time fuck with his older neighbour Tony Minghetti (from Daddy"s Cigar 3 and 6 and Malboro Tony 1 and 2)...

Added: 02-Jan-2013

Rating: 7.67
Read...
Me and David: Part 1 8.75: vote

The start of a love story, with my friend...

Added: 30-Dec-2012

Rating: 8.75
Read...
Uh Oh...Forgot My Change 10.00: vote

I didn"t have money for the ice cream man, but he had something better in mind...

Added: 17-Mar-2013

Rating: 10.00
Read...
First Time In a Dark Room 7.00: vote

My first gay experience in a cruising spot!

Added: 30-Jan-2013

Rating: 7.00
Read...
My first cock 7.80: vote

It started in a bar that I had frequented after work...

Added: 10-Apr-2012

Rating: 7.80
Read...
What my teacher taught me 8.62: vote

The story of my first time with a man, and the college teacher that made it all happen...

Added: 27-Dec-2012

Rating: 8.62
Read...
A broken disc 3.50: vote

Best friends snuggle and more when their dvd doesn"t work...

Added: 08-Aug-2012

Rating: 3.50
Read...
Losing my Virginity 8.73: vote

Losing my virginity to Luke, a curious guy with a big dick...

Added: 19-Mar-2012

Rating: 8.73
Read...
My First Time... Was the worst time... 6.80: vote

It happened with a friend...

Added: 16-Jul-2012

Rating: 6.80
Read...
It must not happen 4.12: vote

My first time having sex with a guy...

Added: 27-Oct-2012

Rating: 4.12
Read...
Patrick Duffy 8.33: vote

My first time sex story...

Added: 29-Jun-2012

Rating: 8.33
Read...
Young Marine in Hawaii 8.33: vote

First time I bottomed, and with a special tranny girl...

Added: 27-Apr-2012

Rating: 8.33
Read...
The Best Pain : Part Two 8.22: vote

Elijah realizes that Martin is only using him. After high school lets out for the year and he"s freed of Martin he meets the sexy red-head, Savion, who barely knows him but seems to care an awful lot...

Added: 09-May-2012

Rating: 8.22
Read...
Gay sexual experience with piano teacher 10.00: vote

100% fictional and its my first time so no hate please...

Added: 03-Jan-2013

Rating: 10.00
Read...
First Time in a long time! 7.40: vote

First time was the BEST TIME with someone I meet on the Internet...

Added: 01-Dec-2012

Rating: 7.40
Read...
My First Time with Mark 5.50: vote

The story of the first dick that I sucked...

Added: 27-Sep-2012

Rating: 5.50
Read...
My First guy on guy action ever 3.00: vote

My first time with a guy I meet at Starbucks...

Added: 23-Jun-2012

Rating: 3.00
Read...
First anal in car 4.80: vote

First car anal sex...

Added: 25-Feb-2013

Rating: 4.80
Read...
Could you do me a favor? 3.50: vote

Max is surprised when Alex asks him for something...

Added: 11-Mar-2012

Rating: 3.50
Read...
My first time with Jose 3.00: vote

Just turned 18. Met a guy on CL had hot steamy ass fucking fun...

Added: 08-Jul-2012

Rating: 3.00
Read...
The murder last sunday 0: vote

Chance has always understood the law. But he could never follow threw with it, he was a full fledged criminal and had a huge bounty. The only weird thing for him was..... He was in love with a male cop named Tyrese...

Added: 23-Feb-2012

Rating: 0
Read...
Femboy Vacation Sex 9.46: vote

I get mistaken for a girl on the beach and meet some sexy young men. Partially true story...

Added: 10-Feb-2013

Rating: 9.46
Read...
Building up to my First Experience with a Guy 10.00: vote

Finally experiencing my first time with a Guy after years of fantasizing...

Added: 16-May-2012

Rating: 10.00
Read...
The Recluse : Part 1 6.00: vote

Allen, an Asian American boy with a dark secret finds himself struggling to get by after a huge tragedy. But a long forgotten friend pulls him through...

Added: 29-Jun-2012

Rating: 6.00
Read...
My First Time with a Guy : Part I 8.67: vote

Finally experiencing my first time with a Guy after years of fantasizing...

Added: 16-May-2012

Rating: 8.67
Read...
First time with neighbour 6.50: vote

First time fucked by neighbour...

Added: 22-Jun-2012

Rating: 6.50
Read...
My first gay sex 6.50: vote

My first gay sex at 18 yrs old...

Added: 27-Aug-2012

Rating: 6.50
Read...
My First Time with Mark II 9.25: vote

A continuation of my relationship with Mark...

Added: 28-Sep-2012

Rating: 9.25
Read...
A Way With Words 10.00: vote

Things heat up between Steven and Chris after Chris tries to convince his old school friend that he is gay. But is there more going on than meets the eye?

Added: 04-Jul-2012

Rating: 10.00
Read...
My first time with a guy 6.82: vote

I was surprised when a long time friend found me in womens clothing. This is a real story...

Added: 26-Feb-2012

Rating: 6.82
Read...
First time dressing for john 8.37: vote

First time crossdressing for my 45 year old friend with benefits...

Added: 30-Jul-2012

Rating: 8.37
Read...
First Time at the Gym 5.83: vote

My first time with a man...

Added: 11-Oct-2012

Rating: 5.83
Read...
Oral Sub 9.50: vote

My first time as an oral slave...

Added: 06-Jul-2012

Rating: 9.50
Read...
Business trip, 2nd time 7.87: vote

this is the true story of the 2nd time I let a guy fuck me...

Added: 03-Mar-2012

Rating: 7.87
Read...
Blown Off Shore 4.33: vote

Aboard that ship is where my first real sexual memory of thinking of another guy took place...

Added: 25-Feb-2013

Rating: 4.33
Read...
My first time in the hot tub - Stories from the Spa : Part 1 4.00: vote

A college boy sees an older friend and finds out what happens when the two feel comfortable naked with one another in a hot tub...

Added: 02-Dec-2012

Rating: 4.00
Read...
Best Friends 7.54: vote

My best friend hurts himself and is disabled for a few weeks. This is a semi-fiction story...

Added: 24-Apr-2013

Rating: 7.54
Read...
My 1st time at a gay club 5.00: vote

No sex in this story just writing about my first experience at a gay club...

Added: 31-May-2013

Rating: 5.00
Read...
First time with Brian. 8.00: vote

This is my first time with Brian after chatting to him online for almost 2 years...

Added: 15-Apr-2012

Rating: 8.00
Read...
Day at the Dog Park 9.17: vote

My first time. I was 18 and I meet him via online ad...

Added: 30-Sep-2012

Rating: 9.17
Read...
My First Time was a Threesome (spit-roast) 7.63: vote

One evening I was messaged by a guy named Bob and we started chatting and he asked if I would like to bottom for him and his friend (Ron). After looking over some pictures of the two guys and their cocks I decided it would be really dumb of me not to truly consider the offer...

Added: 20-Aug-2012

Rating: 7.63
Read...
Under neath the Texas sun 8.00: vote

Josh has only one wish for his senior year, to win the state marching competition. Josh meets Daniel, the new sexy guy in the band and anything can happen under neath the Texas sun...

Added: 17-Feb-2012

Rating: 8.00
Read...
My First time with Mark III 6.80: vote

A continuation of Mark II...

Added: 10-Oct-2012

Rating: 6.80
Read...
First time anal 5.50: vote

I finally went for it...

Added: 05-Apr-2012

Rating: 5.50
Read...
I want your cum 5.75: vote

How I love to swallow...

Added: 28-Apr-2013

Rating: 5.75
Read...
First fuck - in the backseat! 2.00: vote

Alex and Imran fuck in the car...

Added: 16-Sep-2012

Rating: 2.00
Read...
Conner"s Story : Part 2 9.67: vote

Part 2 Of Conner"s Story. In this part It tells the story of how Conner met his now only friend and his first time...

Added: 04-Aug-2012

Rating: 9.67
Read...
Boring quiet Home alone turned to Amazing weekend 6.33: vote

My parents gone for the memorial weekend and I was home alone for the whole weekend but then my friend slept over the whole weekend...

Added: 27-May-2012

Rating: 6.33
Read...
Hot Italian friend 9.09: vote

See what happens when we get drunk...

Added: 23-Oct-2012

Rating: 9.09
Read...
Finally got pounded 8.13: vote

My first time getting pounded!

Added: 18-Apr-2012

Rating: 8.13
Read...
Bills Last Day 6.41: vote

A sailor enlistment is up and he has a farewell meeting with one of his shipmates...

Added: 02-Oct-2012

Rating: 6.41
Read...
Could this get any better? 9.43: vote

The new boy at tristons high school starts to catch his eye!

Added: 06-Apr-2013

Rating: 9.43
Read...
The Freshman 9.47: vote

My first time with my big dicked roommate...

Added: 27-Apr-2012

Rating: 9.47
Read...
My weakness: A skater jock 7.30: vote

My coming out and first time with a guy...

Added: 04-Jun-2012

Rating: 7.30
Read...
Doing Time 4.40: vote

Rhys Connistion, a serial shoplifter and pickpocket, has been sentenced to a short custodial sentence by the courts.""In an environment where violence and danger are ever present can he tell friend from foe? Who can he trust when nothing is quite as it seems?

Added: 15-Sep-2012

Rating: 4.40
Read...
Jacuzzi first time sex 4.33: vote

Sucking my first cock...

Added: 22-Feb-2012

Rating: 4.33
Read...
I did not know I had a disorder 9.00: vote

Roger is bisexual. Roger posts on Craigslist for oral. Ray responds. They agree to meet and Ray wants to include a she-male. She-male cannot made the date so Roger is told to dress up for Ray...

Added: 27-Mar-2012

Rating: 9.00
Read...
Asian First Time 5.12: vote

My first time with boy in detail...

Added: 19-Mar-2012

Rating: 5.12
Read...
First Time Gay Experience with Mature Guy 7.40: vote

True story of my first time gay sex experience...

Added: 14-Jun-2012

Rating: 7.40
Read...
My first time with my bestfriend 8.25: vote

Josh and Xavier have been bestfriends for a while and an adventure strikes...

Added: 21-Aug-2012

Rating: 8.25
Read...
Sleepover led to first time 6.83: vote

An innocent sleepover which led to my first time with man or woman...

Added: 18-Oct-2012

Rating: 6.83
Read...

 

Pages: [<<] 1 2 3 4 5 6 [>>]

Hop to:
Search
Random Me and him: Part 5

Finally it happens...

Read...