Unlikely

"OH MY GOD... I'M GOING... TO CUM," He moaned as he picked up the pace of his thrusting.

"ME... TOO." I could barely get that much out before I cummed all over my chest and his hand. My ass tensed up and squeezed hard on his cock as he cummed deep inside me, filling me with his juice, and collapsed on top of me and we lay there panting. His cock went soft and fell out of me.

Tears started up again.

"What's wrong, baby?" He wrapped his arms around me.

"Nothing is," I smiled at him through the tears, "I'm just so happy you found me again."

He kissed me softly. "You have no idea how long I've wanted to hold you. I missed you so much."

I looked around the room we were in and wondered what would have happened if my father hadn't completely lost it. Would we have done this years ago? I glanced at the clock, it was 1 AM and I really didn't want to be taking the subway that late at night.

"Do you mind if I sleep here with you tonight?"

"I wouldn't have it any other way."

We showered together and after drying off we went back to his bed.

He wrapped his arms around me and I fell asleep feeling his chest on my back.

<%PART%>

The next morning I was woken up by him kissing the back of my neck.

"Good morning, babe." He whispered softly in my ear and sent shivers down my spine.

"Good morning, babe." I was groggy when I replied but somehow I managed to form the words.

We lay in bed together for a while, I really didn't want to get up and leave the warmth and shelter his arms provided. I finally realized I hadn't told my mother I was going to be staying out that night. She was overprotective but she meant well. I knew she probably had been up most of the night.

"Sorry, Dave, I need to go get my phone, my mom is probably having a shit fit by now and running all over the neighborhood calling everyone to see if they know where I am."

He reluctantly released me. As I walked over to get my phone from the jeans that I had worn the previous day I looked back to see him staring at my ass as I walked. I winked at him and he winked back. When I bent over to take my phone out he whistled at me.

"Shit," I thought to myself, "6 missed calls from mom, plus 3 texts. She's gonna be pissed."

I dialed her phone. One ring... Two rings... "COLIN WHERE THE HELL ARE YOU I'VE BEEN WORRIED SICK."

"Um... I... I..."

"Colin, just tell me what happened."

"I... I..." Dave walked over and took the phone from me. I glared at him but he didn't give it back. I mouthed "She doesn't know I'm gay." He nodded. He put it on speaker.

"Hi Mrs. Connor, it's Dave. I used to live two doors down from you guys?"

"Dave? What the hell is going on?"

I jumped in. "We met on the street by complete coincidence and he invited me over. It got late and I didn't want to wake you in case you had fallen asleep or I would have called. Dave didn't want me to take the subway so he let me sleep on their couch."

Mom seemed to still be in shock that after five years Dave and I would run into each other by fluke. "Ok, then sweetie, I wish you had called me though. Bye."

"Bye Mom."

"Bye Mrs. Connor."

As we got off the phone it hit me that Dave really didn't know what happened to my mother and me. I mean he probably had some idea since he knew about how horrible my father was. He definitely didn't know that we lived in a dumpy apartment that could fit in his living room, that my mom worked three jobs to get by, or that I had to turn down Brown, Columbia, and Princeton because I need a full ride or there is no way I could go to college. I'm going to Fordham next year on a full ride, and it's still obviously a good school but it would have been nice to go to an Ivy League.

Dave smiled at me again. His naked body looked amazing even in the dim light filtering through the curtains into his room. His stomach rumbled, it was noon and we hadn't eaten since we ate sushi the previous night. I suggested that we eat and he chuckled.

There wasn't much food in the apartment, at least not much substantial food, so we decided to go out. I didn't feel like putting on my cum soaked jeans or underwear so I borrowed a pair of shorts, underwear, a hoodie, and a t-shirt from Dave. They smelled like him.

"I know of good burger join a couple blocks from here, on me," Dave always had liked burgers, it didn't surprise me that he suggested that.

"Sounds good."

As we walked he grabbed my hand. My arm tingled as we walked.

"Fuck." I muttered under my breath.

"What? Did I do something wrong?"

"No, across the street, it's Nick." I put my hood up and hoped he hadn't seen me. What are the odds of him of all people being here?

"Who?"

"The guy who hit on you Thursday."

"Oh, well what's the problem with that?"

"He doesn't know I'm gay, and he hit on me when he thought I was straight, this would just make it so much worse."

As we were standing on the street talking about it Nick walked up. This was going to be bad.

"Hey, Nick." (Subtext: "Oh fuck oh fuck oh fuck oh fuck oh fuck.")

"So... Um... What's up?" (Subtext: "My supposedly straight friend is holding hands with the waiter who rejected me three days ago, what the fuck?")

I didn't know how to respond. I thought of a number of things to say, none of them made the situation less awkward. I settled on one that seemed marginally better than the rest. "Um... Well... This is Dave, he used to be my neighbor back before I moved into the city." (Subtext: "Don't wanna talk about it, please can we not talk about it.")

"So why are you holding hands and why do you have a hickey?" Busted.

"So I guess claiming that we're just friends isn't gonna work here?"

"Believe it or not, no. I've been in love with you for years, I had held out hope that you were gay and that you might come to feel for me the way I feel about you."

"I... Um... I..." I had no idea how to respond.

Dave saw that I was floundering and cut in. "I used to be Colin's neighbor before he moved to the city. I was in love with him then and have been in love with him since. Even after years of not seeing him I still wanted nothing more than to have him in my arms. When he came into the restaurant it took all of my willpower not to kiss him right there, and when you all left I thought I had missed my chance. I noticed that he dropped his phone though, so when he came back to get it I said the only way I would give it back to him is if he came on a date with me. If you want to be pissed that's fine, be pissed at me, not at him."

Nick looked at me like someone had driven a dagger through his heart. "What could he have that I don't. You haven't even seen him for years, you've never talked about him, how could you possibly think he could care about you like I do!? He's just some guy, he could never care for you like I do." Tears started to pool in the corners of his eyes.

I lost it. "When almost everything in my life was going wrong, Dave was the one I ran to. You have no idea what my life used to be like so how could you possibly think you could ever compare to him!"

Nick burst into tears and ran off. I felt bad for hurting him but I couldn't help myself. How could he possibly understand what Dave means to me.

We walked to the burger place but I just wanted to go back to Dave's apartment. I wanted to be alone with him. I didn't want to have something like what just happened with Nick happen again.

<%PART%>

Nick walked through the park, down to the pond where children would be playing with their motor boats and their families would sit and watch. They were always so happy. Whenever he was upset this cheered him up. He sat down on a bench and looked at the water.

"Who the fuck does that Dave guy think he is. Colin has been my friend for years, I've never heard him even talk about a Dave. This is such bullshit."

"Hey, faggot." Nick turned and saw John.

"Of course," Nick thought to himself, "This day just keeps getting better."

"Don't you have something better to do with your time than kick me when I'm down? Much as I'm normally not in the mood to deal with your bullshit, I'm especially not in the mood right now."

"Awe? Something wrong, fucking queer?"

Nick glared at him.

"Oooh, scary fairy."

Nick lost it. He stood up and tackled John to the ground. He sat on top of John's chest and drew his arm back to punch him in the face. Nick may have had surprise on his side but that was about all he had going for him. John threw Nick off of him and held him down.

"What's your problem, asshole? Why do you always need be such a dick to me? It's not like me being gay hurts you in some way."

"Shut up faggot."

"What is your problem with me, what did I ever do to you?"

"I said shut up!"

"What the fuck is your..."

John leaned in and kissed him.

Nick was disgusted. "What the fuck is wrong with you? You make fun of me for being gay every day of my life and then you go and kiss me?"

"Why do you have to make me feel this way? I was never this way until you came around. I was happy and straight and then I met you and now I can't get you out of my head. I can't even enjoy sex with my girlfriend without imagining it's you I'm with and not her."

Nick looked up at John. Admittedly he was pretty attractive. He had never really noticed how blue John's eyes were until now, or how nice a smile he had. In all fairness that's because usually John was staring daggers at him and making him run away in fear, but he seemed totally different now. Nick went through a list of the things that he knew about John beyond homophobic asshole, which now turned out to be a coverup. He was kind to basically everyone else, so now would probably be kind to him. He was taking a lot of AP's and from what he heard was doing well in them, and had a full ride to Duke for basketball. Nick was on the Yearbook committee and knew that John had been voted Most Likely to Succeed, Most Athletic, and Best Smile. Really he was a catch. "Maybe he's not so bad," Nick thought to himself.

"I'm so so sorry for all the pain I've caused you. I would completely understand if you never wanted to see me again or if you outed me to everyone." John got off of Nick and sat down in the grass next to him. Normally Nick would have walked away. Nothing had been normal about today though.

"I can't believe I'm going to talk to you of all people about this. I've had a crush on Colin for as long as I've known him. I always thought he was straight and that's why he never reciprocated. Today I saw him holding hands with the most gorgeous guy I have ever seen, and apparently they've been friends since they were kids. How the hell am I supposed to compete with that? I have always been so sure Colin would be mine somehow. Now I just don't think it could ever happen."

"Then be with me."

"What?"

"Be with me. I promise I won't ever hurt you again. I want to be with you so badly, I just have never felt like I could admit it. You've always been so comfortable with who you are. I it's so attractive, but it's so infuriating when I can't be like that myself."

"I don't know, you've been so horrible to me the entire time I've known you, why should I expect now to be any different? Why should I trust you?"

"You shouldn't. Nothing about me should convince you, I don't have anything to offer that can prove how sincere I am. I need to you believe me though. Please believe me."

Tears were starting to well up in John's eyes. Nick sat up, put his hand on John's face, and wiped them away.

"I believe you."

"Really?"

"Yes."

John placed a hand on Nick's cheek and softly stroked it, then pulled him in to kiss him.

"Thank you. Thank you so much." Somehow losing Colin didn't seem quite so bad.

~~~~~~~~

We had just finished fucking again. It was better than last night had been, though that may have been because my ass had already experienced Dave's cock before. Dave had his arms around me and was softly caressing my back. My head was resting on his chest. I was afraid I was dreaming and would wake up and none of this would have happened.

'Cause if you liked it then you should have put a ring on it
If you liked it then you should have put a ring on it
Don't be mad when you see that he wants it
'Cause if you liked it then you

I picked my phone up off Dave's bedside table.

"Hey Jenn."

"Hey Colin, what are you doing now?"

"Remember that waiter from Thursday?"

"The one whose ass you were staring at?"

"Yeah, him."

"What about him?"

"I guess you could say he's my boyfriend now, I'm with him right now." Dave blushed.

"Ok well bring him along, Tony and Jesse are getting Nick and we're going to the Central Park Zoo and then for dinner, you ditched us at the movie so you better not miss this too."

"Nick saw us, he was pissed."

"Really? I just talked to him like two minutes ago, he seemed fine."

"Let me ask Dave if he want's to come." Dave nodded. "Ok yeah we can come. We'll meet you guys there in like twenty minutes."

We reluctantly got out of bed and put clothes on. Twenty minutes later we arrived at the zoo. Tony, Jesse and Jenn were there already.

"Well aren't you lucky, Colin, he's a looker." She whispered to me as we got there.

"Um, guys, this is Dave, he's... well... he's..."

"I'm his boyfriend." Dave put his arm around me and kissed me on the cheeks.

Jesse and Tony laughed. "I told you, Tony. You said Colin wouldn't do it until he went to college but I knew it."

"Damnit Jesse, fuck, ok, I owe you dinner."

"What are you two talking about?" I stood there perplexed.

"Jesse and me had a bet on when you would come out. I thought you would take longer. Apparently she was right."

"Jenn, did you tell them?"

"Not until they asked me like two years ago."

"You guys have known for that long?"

"It was kind of obvious, a guy as good looking as you couldn't go that long without a girlfriend unless he just didn't want one. The fact that you stare at every good looking guy who walks near you didn't hurt either." Tony and Jesse laughed.

"Hey everyone." Nick walked up and joined us standing at the entrance to the zoo.

Tony said, "Um, Nick, I think you might want to look behind you." Except for Dave and Nick, everyone turned to John and glared.

"What the fuck are you doing here asshole? And why the fuck were you following Nick?" Jesse was really protective of her friends. She was small but fuck could she be scary.

John stared at the ground looking guilty until Nick went over and kissed him on the lips. "It's OK guys, I told him to come."

Every jaw dropped.

"Ok can you please explain why hell is freezing over?" Tony spoke for everyone, except for Dave who had no idea what a momentous thing just happened.

John stammered. "I, um... I... have kind of always... well... as long as I have known... ever since I first laid eyes on..."

Nick cut in to save him from further embarrassment. "He made fun of me so people wouldn't think he was gay, least of all me."

"Yeah, I guess that kind of sums it up." John blushed.

Stunned silence.

Jenn broke it. "Are you sure Nick?"

"Yeah."

We all were puzzled but if Nick was OK with it we all were, except for Jesse. "Fine, I'll be nice to you for Nick's sake. But if you hurt him, or you go into school Monday and go back to making fun of him, so help me God I will out you and then beat the shit out of you myself." We all knew she could and would.

"Don't worry, he won't." Nick kissed him again and we went into the zoo. We walked through our normal circuit, seeing as much as we could with as little walking as possibly. We had long ago mapped it out. We would always stop to see if we could actually see the red pandas, usually we failed. Invariably Nick would comment on how cute the polar bears are before someone else would cut in and point out that they're still bears and will rip your face off if given a chance. This time it was me. We continued in a somewhat predictable fashion through the zoo, with our two newcomers in toe. We finished seeing anything and were leaving when we saw three of John's friends. Matty was about 5'7" and overweight, and dumb as a post. Joe was slightly taller and in moderately better shape, but made Matty look like an astrophysicist. That brings us to Doug. Doug was tall and handsome, and wasn't quite as moronic as the others, but had a huge temper.

They saw us and decided to come over and do what they did best, be assholes. Matty decided to get the ball rolling. "Hey John what are you doing with the faggot and his friends?" He noticed that Dave and I were holding hands. "Oh looks like there are even more faggots now." Tony and Jenn had already grabbed onto Jesse, or Matty would have been on the ground with several bruises forming. "Seriously dude, what the fuck are you doing with these fags?" John's face went beat red. "What's wrong dude?" John clenched his fists. "Um... dude, why aren't you making fun of the fags?"

John went ape shit. He walked up to Matty and with one punch to the gut had him on the ground. "That 'fag' is my boyfriend, and if you ever call him that again I will beat the shit out of you."

Joe cracked up. "Wait, you're telling me you're a fag too? That's priceless."

If it was a Looney Tunes cartoon John's head would have exploded by now. "Yeah, I'm a fag, but you know what, if you keep it up, you're gonna get the shit kicked out of you by a fag." Joe backed off, he knew John would destroy him.

Doug was more biting than the other two. While they were blunt and generally stupid, Doug decided to say something he knew would destroy John. He walked right up to him and got in his face. "So basically you have been an asshole to someone for the last three years because you're in love with him. Nothing they just said was any worse than stuff you said even two days ago." John was just standing there. The color left his face. Doug punched him twice, his first one landed just beneath his left eye, the landed square in the middle of his gut. John crumbled to the ground. "Faggot." It somehow sounded more disdainful than usual.

Jesse finally got away from Jenn and Tony, within a second or two she was on top of him and landing blows to his face. Like I said, the girl was scary if you were on her bad side. She was pissed before but now she was furious. "LEAVE HIM THE FUCK ALONE!" I pulled out my phone and took a picture. Tony, Jenn, and Dave finally pulled her off. Her knuckles were bloody

"Know what's funny, assholes?" I took a great deal of pleasure saying this. "The three of you big tough guys just got the shit kicked out of you by a fag and a girl. These are some nice pictures of it too. If you ever try to pull that shit again, everyone in school is going to have some nice laughs at your expense." They backed off.

Nick ran over to John and helped him up.

Jesse then did something that was almost as surprising as John winding up Nick's boyfriend. "Sorry John, I may have been a little harsh earlier." Tony stood in amazement, the only time Jesse had ever apologized to him was when she accidentally dropped his phone in the toilet for the third time.

"It's fine Jesse, I deserved it. I was an asshole to a guy I loved for years, I really don't deserve him." John had clearly been affected by what Doug had said.

Nick kissed him softly on the lips. "It's ok baby, I forgive you. I'm sure I'll think of a way for you to make it up to me." He winked at his new boyfriend. "If you guys don't mind my parents are out of town so I'm going to take John back to my place and do unspeakable things to him." John blushed as Nick took his hand and they walked towards the subway.

"Jesse and I should probably split too, don't want her walking around the city with blood on her hands." Tony and Jesse started walking towards his apartment building.

Jenn, Dave, and I were left standing by the seals in the middle of the zoo. Jenn pulled out her phone "Oh look at the time, I have to go do a thing." She made it obvious she just wanted to let us be alone. As she walked off Dave kissed me softly and said I should come back to his place with him. Much as I wanted to, I knew my mom would be worried. Even though I could just call her I felt like after stressing her out so much last night I really should go home. I told him I would talk to him later. He took it quite literally, as soon as we parted my phone buzzed and I had a text message from him. "I love you <3" I turned around and winked at him as looked back at me and waved.

"Fuck, I hope mom isn't too pissed at me for last night." That thought weighed on me the entire way back home.

--------------
If I get good feedback I might write some more, but would really appreciate some feedback either way. I know I probably should have included more sex but I primarily wanted to build some characters and give some background here so that if I do write another I can actually have something to build upon rather than just have it be a series of random hook ups.